A popular independent café in Gloucester Docks could close before Christmas. David Purchase, who has run On Toast since 2011, says he is ‘seriously considering’ shutting after a long dispute with Severn Trent Water over the water fittings in the building.
How the dispute started
Severn Trent first visited the café in June 2025, without tools, took some photographs and then emailed a report. Mr Purchase says the report told him that his water supply posed an immediate risk to public health and that three valves needed replacing, including one on the boiler and one on the toilet cistern.
Mr Purchase says the boiler and toilet were his landlord’s responsibility. He says he asked Severn Trent to contact the landlord, and that the company did not do so. He was told that under the Water Industry Act 1991, the water bill payer can be held responsible for the fittings.
Court and costs
Severn Trent took the case to Cheltenham Magistrates’ Court in September to obtain a warrant to carry out the work. Mr Purchase represented himself, as he could not find a solicitor to take the case. The warrant was granted.
He now has to pay a bill of £13,400. This covers the contractor’s work at £317.38, court costs of £2,238 and £10,844.47 towards Severn Trent’s solicitor. He says he has halted the 28-day deadline to pay by asking for a VAT invoice and an itemised bill, and that he is appealing the costs.
Mr Purchase says the legislation is out of date and gives no right of appeal or independent second opinion. In a Facebook post he said On Toast would be ‘finished by Christmas’ because of the costs, not because of the economy.
Reaction
Customers and other businesses in the Docks have sent messages of support, and some have suggested a crowdfunding page. Alex McIntyre, the Labour MP for Gloucester, said his office had supported Mr Purchase since the issue was first raised. He wants a ‘common-sense solution’ that keeps the café open now that the legal process is over.
A Severn Trent spokesperson said the matter is the subject of ongoing litigation, so it would be inappropriate to comment further.
What it means for other business owners
Mr Purchase says he wants people to know what happened to him, and that the rules affect other businesses and homeowners as well. Water companies can inspect premises under the water fittings rules and can take legal action when they find problems.

